Same buck?

[Cullen bohannon]

Trail cam pics are of a buck I hunted all last season. Got pics of him until his rack fell off. This year I killed a buck that looked exactly like him, except the right side of his rack crooked out and he lost a small point. Could an injury cause this? I'm almost 99% sure its same deer.

 

[muddhunter]

Looks like the same deer.

 

[aaronc]

I vote yep,....cool deer too. Congrads

 

[120+]

Yes, has to be.

 

[RackedUP]

I'm pretty positive it's the same buck.

 

[bowhunter269]

My vote is yes ! Congrats !

 

[huntr467]

I am going against the grain here and saying that NO that is definitely not the same buck.
Dead deer has curved right beam tip and curved brows. the buck in the trail cam pic has straight brows and a right beam that curves inward.

 

[SmokeShow]

I'm thinking no... was there a missing G4 on the right side antler? Its shows in the cam pics but not in the dead deer pics. Also the funky curved right beam tip on the dead deer doesn't show up in the cam pics. And the dead deer appears to have equal length brow tines whereas the deer in the cam pic appears to have brow tines that are not the same length - left side longer.


They sure might be related though with both having funky right sides?

 

[samjoe]

imma say yes.Good one by the way!

 

[Chaneydmd]

Looks like it probably is to me. Nice Eastern KY buck


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Cullen bohannon]

Thanks guys. That's what threw me off was the right beam that curvd out and a missing point, I'm guessing is what you're saying is the g4? The rest seem to be identical. Would an injury of some sort do that to his right antler

 

[mulehead]

Mister obvious says not the same deer

 

[WildmanWilson]

Nope. Different deer.

 

[Jde]

I'm saying its him


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[WILD]

Looks different to me also..I would say not the same,but close.